# Copyright (c) 2017 Cisco and/or its affiliates. # Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License"); # you may not use this file except in compliance with the License. # You may obtain a copy of the License at: # # http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0 # # Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software # distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS, # WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied. # See the License for the specific language governing permissions and # limitations under the License. *** Settings *** | Resource | resources/libraries/robot/performance/performance_setup.robot | Resource | resources/libraries/robot/crypto/ipsec.robot | ... | Force Tags | 3_NODE_SINGLE_LINK_TOPO | PERFTEST | HW_ENV | NDRPDRDISC | ... | IP4FWD | IPSEC | IPSECHW | IPSECTUN | NIC_Intel-XL710 | BASE | ... | Suite Setup | Set up IPSec performance test suite | L3 | Intel-XL710 | ... | HW_cryptodev | ... | Suite Teardown | Tear down 3-node performance topology | ... | Test Setup | Set up performance test | ... | Test Teardown | Tear down performance discovery test | ${min_rate}pps | ... | ${framesize} | ${traffic_profile} | ... | Documentation | *IPv4 IPsec tunnel mode performance test suite.* | ... | ... | *[Top] Network Topologies:* TG-DUT1-DUT2-TG 3-node circular topology | ... | with single links between nodes. | ... | *[Enc] Packet Encapsulations:* Eth-IPv4 on TG-DUTn, | ... | Eth-IPv4-IPSec on DUT1-DUT2 | ... | *[Cfg] DUT configuration:* DUT1 and DUT2 are configured with multiple | ... | IPsec tunnels between them. DUTs get IPv4 traffic from TG, encrypt it | ... | and send to another DUT, where packets are decrypted and sent back to TG | ... | *[Ver] TG verification:* TG finds and reports throughput NDR (Non Drop | ... | Rate) with zero packet loss tolerance or throughput PDR (Partial Drop | ... | Rate) with non-zero packet loss tolerance (LT) expressed in number | ... | of packets transmitted. NDR is discovered for different | ... | number of IPsec tunnels using binary search algorithms with configured | ... | starting rate and final step that determines throughput measurement | ... | resolution. Test packets are generated by TG on | ... | links to DUTs. TG traffic profile contains two L3 flow-groups | ... | (flow-group per direction, number of flows per flow-group equals to | ... | number of IPSec tunnels) with all packets | ... | containing Ethernet header, IPv4 header with IP protocol=61 and | ... | static payload. MAC addresses are matching MAC addresses of the TG | ... | node interfaces. Incrementing of IP.dst (IPv4 destination address) field | ... | is applied to both streams. | ... | *[Ref] Applicable standard specifications:* RFC4303 and RFC2544. *** Variables *** # XL710-DA2 bandwidth limit ~49Gbps/2=24.5Gbps | ${s_24.5G}= | ${24500000000} # XL710-DA2 Mpps limit 37.5Mpps/2=18.75Mpps | ${s_18.75Mpps}= | ${18750000} | ${tg_if1_ip4}= | 192.168.10.2 | ${dut1_if1_ip4}= | 192.168.10.1 | ${dut1_if2_ip4}= | 172.168.1.1 | ${dut2_if1_ip4}= | 172.168.1.2 | ${dut2_if2_ip4}= | 192.168.20.1 | ${tg_if2_ip4}= | 192.168.20.2 | ${raddr_ip4}= | 20.0.0.0 | ${laddr_ip4}= | 10.0.0.0 | ${addr_range}= | ${32} | ${ipsec_overhead}= | ${58} | ${n_tunnels}= | ${1} # Traffic profile: | ${traffic_profile}= | trex-sl-3n-ethip4-ip4dst${n_tunnels} *** Test Cases *** | tc01-64B-1t1c-ethip4ipsecbasetnl-ip4base-tnl-cbc-sha1-ndrdisc | | [Documentation] | | ... | [Cfg] DUTs run 1 IPsec tunnel CBC-SHA1 in each direction, configured\ | | ... | with 1 thread, 1 phy core, 1 receive queue per NIC port. | | ... | [Ver] Find NDR for 64 Byte frames\ | | ... | using binary search start at 40GE linerate, step 50kpps. | | ... | | [Tags] | 64B | 1T1C | STHREAD | NDRDISC | | ... | | # FIXME: Move repeated lines into a keyword. | | ${framesize}= | Set Variable | ${64} | | ${min_rate}= | Set Variable | ${50000} | | ${max_rate}= | Set Variable | ${s_18.75Mpps} | | ${binary_min}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${binary_max}= | Set Variable | ${max_rate} | | ${threshold}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${encr_alg}= | Crypto Alg AES CBC 128 | | ${auth_alg}= | Integ Alg SHA1 96 | | Given Add '1' worker threads and '1' rxqueues in 3-node single-link circular topology | | And Add PCI devices to DUTs in 3-node single link topology | | And Add no multi seg to all DUTs | | And Add cryptodev to all DUTs | ${1} | | And Add DPDK dev default RXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Add DPDK dev default TXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Apply startup configuration on all VPP DUTs | | When Generate keys for IPSec | ${encr_alg} | ${auth_alg} | | And Initialize IPSec in 3-node circular topology | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut1} | ${raddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | | ... | ${dut1_if2} | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut2} | ${laddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | | ... | ${dut2_if1} | | And VPP IPsec Add Multiple Tunnels | | ... | ${dut1} | ${dut2} | ${dut1_if2} | ${dut2_if1} | ${n_tunnels} | | ... | ${encr_alg} | ${encr_key} | ${auth_alg} | ${auth_key} | | ... | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | ${laddr_ip4} | ${raddr_ip4} | | ... | ${addr_range} | | And Set interfaces in path in 3-node circular topology up | | Then Find NDR using binary search and pps | ${framesize} | | ... | ${binary_min} | ${binary_max} | ${traffic_profile} | | ... | ${min_rate} | ${max_rate} | ${threshold} | tc02-64B-1t1c-ethip4ipsecbasetnl-ip4base-tnl-cbc-sha1-pdrdisc | | [Documentation] | | ... | [Cfg] DUTs run 1 IPsec tunnel CBC-SHA1 in each direction, configured\ | | ... | with 1 thread, 1 phy core, 1 receive queue per NIC port. | | ... | [Ver] Find PDR for 64 Byte frames using binary search start at 40GE\ | | ... | linerate, step 50kpps and loss tolerance of 0.5%. | | ... | | [Tags] | 64B | 1T1C | STHREAD | PDRDISC | SKIP_PATCH | | ... | | ${framesize}= | Set Variable | ${64} | | ${min_rate}= | Set Variable | ${50000} | | ${max_rate}= | Set Variable | ${s_18.75Mpps} | | ${binary_min}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${binary_max}= | Set Variable | ${max_rate} | | ${threshold}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${encr_alg}= | Crypto Alg AES CBC 128 | | ${auth_alg}= | Integ Alg SHA1 96 | | Given Add '1' worker threads and '1' rxqueues in 3-node single-link circular topology | | And Add PCI devices to DUTs in 3-node single link topology | | And Add no multi seg to all DUTs | | And Add cryptodev to all DUTs | ${1} | | And Add DPDK dev default RXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Add DPDK dev default TXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Apply startup configuration on all VPP DUTs | | When Generate keys for IPSec | ${encr_alg} | ${auth_alg} | | And Initialize IPSec in 3-node circular topology | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut1} | ${raddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | | ... | ${dut1_if2} | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut2} | ${laddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | | ... | ${dut2_if1} | | And VPP IPsec Add Multiple Tunnels | | ... | ${dut1} | ${dut2} | ${dut1_if2} | ${dut2_if1} | ${n_tunnels} | | ... | ${encr_alg} | ${encr_key} | ${auth_alg} | ${auth_key} | | ... | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | ${laddr_ip4} | ${raddr_ip4} | | ... | ${addr_range} | | And Set interfaces in path in 3-node circular topology up | | Then Find PDR using binary search and pps | ${framesize} | | ... | ${binary_min} | ${binary_max} | ${traffic_profile} | | ... | ${min_rate} | ${max_rate} | ${threshold} | ${perf_pdr_loss_acceptance} | | ... | ${perf_pdr_loss_acceptance_type} | tc03-1518B-1t1c-ethip4ipsecbasetnl-ip4base-tnl-cbc-sha1-ndrdisc | | [Documentation] | | ... | [Cfg] DUTs run 1 IPsec tunnel CBC-SHA1 in each direction, configured\ | | ... | with 1 thread, 1 phy core, 1 receive queue per NIC port. | | ... | [Ver] Find NDR for 1518 Byte frames\ | | ... | using binary search start at 40GE linerate, step 50kpps. | | ... | | [Tags] | 1518B | 1T1C | STHREAD | NDRDISC | | ... | | ${framesize}= | Set Variable | ${1518} | | ${min_rate}= | Set Variable | ${50000} | | ${max_rate}= | Calculate pps | ${s_24.5G} | ${framesize + ${ipsec_overhead}} | | ${binary_min}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${binary_max}= | Set Variable | ${max_rate} | | ${threshold}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${encr_alg}= | Crypto Alg AES CBC 128 | | ${auth_alg}= | Integ Alg SHA1 96 | | Given Add '1' worker threads and '1' rxqueues in 3-node single-link circular topology | | And Add PCI devices to DUTs in 3-node single link topology | | And Add cryptodev to all DUTs | ${1} | | And Add DPDK dev default RXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Add DPDK dev default TXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Apply startup configuration on all VPP DUTs | | When Generate keys for IPSec | ${encr_alg} | ${auth_alg} | | And Initialize IPSec in 3-node circular topology | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut1} | ${raddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | | ... | ${dut1_if2} | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut2} | ${laddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | | ... | ${dut2_if1} | | And VPP IPsec Add Multiple Tunnels | | ... | ${dut1} | ${dut2} | ${dut1_if2} | ${dut2_if1} | ${n_tunnels} | | ... | ${encr_alg} | ${encr_key} | ${auth_alg} | ${auth_key} | | ... | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | ${laddr_ip4} | ${raddr_ip4} | | ... | ${addr_range} | | And Set interfaces in path in 3-node circular topology up | | Then Find NDR using binary search and pps | ${framesize} | | ... | ${binary_min} | ${binary_max} | ${traffic_profile} | | ... | ${min_rate} | ${max_rate} | ${threshold} | tc04-1518B-1t1c-ethip4ipsecbasetnl-ip4base-tnl-cbc-sha1-pdrdisc | | [Documentation] | | ... | [Cfg] DUTs run 1 IPsec tunnel CBC-SHA1 in each direction, configured\ | | ... | with 1 thread, 1 phy core, 1 receive queue per NIC port. | | ... | [Ver] Find PDR for 1518 Byte frames using binary search start at 40GE\ | | ... | linerate, step 50kpps and loss tolerance of 0.5%. | | ... | | [Tags] | 1518B | 1T1C | STHREAD | PDRDISC | SKIP_PATCH | | ... | | ${framesize}= | Set Variable | ${1518} | | ${min_rate}= | Set Variable | ${50000} | | ${max_rate}= | Calculate pps | ${s_24.5G} | ${framesize + ${ipsec_overhead}} | | ${binary_min}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${binary_max}= | Set Variable | ${max_rate} | | ${threshold}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${encr_alg}= | Crypto Alg AES CBC 128 | | ${auth_alg}= | Integ Alg SHA1 96 | | Given Add '1' worker threads and '1' rxqueues in 3-node single-link circular topology | | And Add PCI devices to DUTs in 3-node single link topology | | And Add cryptodev to all DUTs | ${1} | | And Add DPDK dev default RXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Add DPDK dev default TXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Apply startup configuration on all VPP DUTs | | When Generate keys for IPSec | ${encr_alg} | ${auth_alg} | | And Initialize IPSec in 3-node circular topology | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut1} | ${raddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | | ... | ${dut1_if2} | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut2} | ${laddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | | ... | ${dut2_if1} | | And VPP IPsec Add Multiple Tunnels | | ... | ${dut1} | ${dut2} | ${dut1_if2} | ${dut2_if1} | ${n_tunnels} | | ... | ${encr_alg} | ${encr_key} | ${auth_alg} | ${auth_key} | | ... | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | ${laddr_ip4} | ${raddr_ip4} | | ... | ${addr_range} | | And Set interfaces in path in 3-node circular topology up | | Then Find PDR using binary search and pps | ${framesize} | | ... | ${binary_min} | ${binary_max} | ${traffic_profile} | | ... | ${min_rate} | ${max_rate} | ${threshold} | ${perf_pdr_loss_acceptance} | | ... | ${perf_pdr_loss_acceptance_type} | tc05-IMIX-1t1c-ethip4ipsecbasetnl-ip4base-tnl-cbc-sha1-ndrdisc | | [Documentation] | | ... | [Cfg] DUTs run 1 IPsec tunnel CBC-SHA1 in each direction, configured\ | | ... | with 1 thread, 1 phy core, 1 receive queue per NIC port. | | ... | [Ver] Find NDR for IMIX_v4_1 frames\ | | ... | using binary search start at 40GE linerate, step 10kpps. | | ... | IMIX_v4_1 = (28x64B; 16x570B; 4x1518B) | | ... | | [Tags] | IMIX | 1T1C | STHREAD | NDRDISC | | ... | | ${framesize}= | Set Variable | IMIX_v4_1 | | ${imix_size}= | Get Frame Size | ${framesize} | | ${min_rate}= | Set Variable | ${10000} | | ${max_rate}= | Calculate pps | ${s_24.5G} | ${imix_size} + ${ipsec_overhead} | | ${binary_min}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${binary_max}= | Set Variable | ${max_rate} | | ${threshold}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${encr_alg}= | Crypto Alg AES CBC 128 | | ${auth_alg}= | Integ Alg SHA1 96 | | Given Add '1' worker threads and '1' rxqueues in 3-node single-link circular topology | | And Add PCI devices to DUTs in 3-node single link topology | | And Add cryptodev to all DUTs | ${1} | | And Add DPDK dev default RXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Add DPDK dev default TXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Apply startup configuration on all VPP DUTs | | When Generate keys for IPSec | ${encr_alg} | ${auth_alg} | | And Initialize IPSec in 3-node circular topology | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut1} | ${raddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | | ... | ${dut1_if2} | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut2} | ${laddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | | ... | ${dut2_if1} | | And VPP IPsec Add Multiple Tunnels | | ... | ${dut1} | ${dut2} | ${dut1_if2} | ${dut2_if1} | ${n_tunnels} | | ... | ${encr_alg} | ${encr_key} | ${auth_alg} | ${auth_key} | | ... | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | ${laddr_ip4} | ${raddr_ip4} | | ... | ${addr_range} | | And Set interfaces in path in 3-node circular topology up | | Then Find NDR using binary search and pps | ${framesize} | | ... | ${binary_min} | ${binary_max} | ${traffic_profile} | | ... | ${min_rate} | ${max_rate} | ${threshold} | tc06-IMIX-1t1c-ethip4ipsecbasetnl-ip4base-tnl-cbc-sha1-pdrdisc | | [Documentation] | | ... | [Cfg] DUTs run 1 IPsec tunnel CBC-SHA1 in each direction, configured\ | | ... | with 1 thread, 1 phy core, 1 receive queue per NIC port. | | ... | [Ver] Find PDR for IMIX_v4_1 frames using binary search start at 40GE\ | | ... | linerate, step 10kpps and loss tolerance of 0.5%. | | ... | IMIX_v4_1 = (28x64B; 16x570B; 4x1518B) | | ... | | [Tags] | IMIX | 1T1C | STHREAD | PDRDISC | SKIP_PATCH | | ... | | ${framesize}= | Set Variable | IMIX_v4_1 | | ${imix_size}= | Get Frame Size | ${framesize} | | ${min_rate}= | Set Variable | ${10000} | | ${max_rate}= | Calculate pps | ${s_24.5G} | ${imix_size} + ${ipsec_overhead} | | ${binary_min}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${binary_max}= | Set Variable | ${max_rate} | | ${threshold}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${encr_alg}= | Crypto Alg AES CBC 128 | | ${auth_alg}= | Integ Alg SHA1 96 | | Given Add '1' worker threads and '1' rxqueues in 3-node single-link circular topology | | And Add PCI devices to DUTs in 3-node single link topology | | And Add cryptodev to all DUTs | ${1} | | And Add DPDK dev default RXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Add DPDK dev default TXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Apply startup configuration on all VPP DUTs | | When Generate keys for IPSec | ${encr_alg} | ${auth_alg} | | And Initialize IPSec in 3-node circular topology | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut1} | ${raddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | | ... | ${dut1_if2} | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut2} | ${laddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | | ... | ${dut2_if1} | | And VPP IPsec Add Multiple Tunnels | | ... | ${dut1} | ${dut2} | ${dut1_if2} | ${dut2_if1} | ${n_tunnels} | | ... | ${encr_alg} | ${encr_key} | ${auth_alg} | ${auth_key} | | ... | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | ${laddr_ip4} | ${raddr_ip4} | | ... | ${addr_range} | | And Set interfaces in path in 3-node circular topology up | | Then Find PDR using binary search and pps | ${framesize} | | ... | ${binary_min} | ${binary_max} | ${traffic_profile} | | ... | ${min_rate} | ${max_rate} | ${threshold} | ${perf_pdr_loss_acceptance} | | ... | ${perf_pdr_loss_acceptance_type} | tc07-64B-2t2c-ethip4ipsecbasetnl-ip4base-tnl-cbc-sha1-ndrdisc | | [Documentation] | | ... | [Cfg] DUTs run 1 IPsec tunnel CBC-SHA1 in each direction, configured\ | | ... | with 2 thread, 2 phy core, 1 receive queue per NIC port. | | ... | [Ver] Find NDR for 64 Byte frames\ | | ... | using binary search start at 40GE linerate, step 50kpps. | | ... | | [Tags] | 64B | 2T2C | MTHREAD | NDRDISC | | ... | | ${framesize}= | Set Variable | ${64} | | ${min_rate}= | Set Variable | ${50000} | | ${max_rate}= | Set Variable | ${s_18.75Mpps} | | ${binary_min}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${binary_max}= | Set Variable | ${max_rate} | | ${threshold}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${encr_alg}= | Crypto Alg AES CBC 128 | | ${auth_alg}= | Integ Alg SHA1 96 | | Given Add '2' worker threads and '1' rxqueues in 3-node single-link circular topology | | And Add PCI devices to DUTs in 3-node single link topology | | And Add no multi seg to all DUTs | | And Add cryptodev to all DUTs | ${2} | | And Add DPDK dev default RXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Add DPDK dev default TXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Apply startup configuration on all VPP DUTs | | When Generate keys for IPSec | ${encr_alg} | ${auth_alg} | | And Initialize IPSec in 3-node circular topology | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut1} | ${raddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | | ... | ${dut1_if2} | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut2} | ${laddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | | ... | ${dut2_if1} | | And VPP IPsec Add Multiple Tunnels | | ... | ${dut1} | ${dut2} | ${dut1_if2} | ${dut2_if1} | ${n_tunnels} | | ... | ${encr_alg} | ${encr_key} | ${auth_alg} | ${auth_key} | | ... | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | ${laddr_ip4} | ${raddr_ip4} | | ... | ${addr_range} | | And Set interfaces in path in 3-node circular topology up | | Then Find NDR using binary search and pps | ${framesize} | | ... | ${binary_min} | ${binary_max} | ${traffic_profile} | | ... | ${min_rate} | ${max_rate} | ${threshold} | tc08-64B-2t2c-ethip4ipsecbasetnl-ip4base-tnl-cbc-sha1-pdrdisc | | [Documentation] | | ... | [Cfg] DUTs run 1 IPsec tunnel CBC-SHA1 in each direction, configured\ | | ... | with 2 thread, 2 phy core, 1 receive queue per NIC port. | | ... | [Ver] Find PDR for 64 Byte frames using binary search start at 40GE\ | | ... | linerate, step 50kpps and loss tolerance of 0.5%. | | ... | | [Tags] | 64B | 2T2C | MTHREAD | PDRDISC | SKIP_PATCH | | ... | | ${framesize}= | Set Variable | ${64} | | ${min_rate}= | Set Variable | ${50000} | | ${max_rate}= | Set Variable | ${s_18.75Mpps} | | ${binary_min}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${binary_max}= | Set Variable | ${max_rate} | | ${threshold}= | Set Variable | ${min_rate} | | ${encr_alg}= | Crypto Alg AES CBC 128 | | ${auth_alg}= | Integ Alg SHA1 96 | | Given Add '2' worker threads and '1' rxqueues in 3-node single-link circular topology | | And Add PCI devices to DUTs in 3-node single link topology | | And Add no multi seg to all DUTs | | And Add cryptodev to all DUTs | ${2} | | And Add DPDK dev default RXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Add DPDK dev default TXD to all DUTs | 2048 | | And Apply startup configuration on all VPP DUTs | | When Generate keys for IPSec | ${encr_alg} | ${auth_alg} | | And Initialize IPSec in 3-node circular topology | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut1} | ${raddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | | ... | ${dut1_if2} | | And Vpp Route Add | ${dut2} | ${laddr_ip4} | 8 | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | | ... | ${dut2_if1} | | And VPP IPsec Add Multiple Tunnels | | ... | ${dut1} | ${dut2} | ${dut1_if2} | ${dut2_if1} | ${n_tunnels} | | ... | ${encr_alg} | ${encr_key} | ${auth_alg} | ${auth_key} | | ... | ${dut1_if2_ip4} | ${dut2_if1_ip4} | ${laddr_ip4} | ${raddr_ip4} | | ... | ${addr_range} | | And Set interfaces in path in 3-node circular topology up | | Then Find PDR using binary search and pps | ${framesize} | | ... | ${binary_min} | ${binary_max} | ${traffic_profile} | | ... | ${min_rate} | ${max_rate} | ${threshold} | ${perf_pdr_loss_acceptance} | | ... | ${perf_pdr_loss_acceptance_type}